Information Technology, Literacy, and Digital Media (Post 2)

As a high school English teacher, the notions of literacy, technology, and digital/media
quite literally intersect on a daily basis. My students are ninth and tenth graders in a rural
South Carolina high school, and they are routinely charged with using technology to research, filter information, and cite responsibly to complete assignments. We are a 1:1 district, and these are
digitally native kids. They Google like they breathe, often and deeply. 


I generally choose to begin with research before a big unit. It helps with mindset, background knowledge,
and “hooks” as students dive deeply into the Salem Witch Trials while simultaneously noticing that McCarthyism looks a great deal like the Puritans. As hysteria and herd mentality prevail, students
must navigate an admittedly choppy ocean of information. My pleas to use Discus databases and
avoid Wikipedia often fall on deaf ears. Or worse, students fall into a pit of Prezi presentations
created by students much like themselves, and thus, the blind lead the blind. I spend months
(MONTHS) teaching citations, and have yet to discover why (like grammar) the formulas are just
not sticky enough to remain firm in the collective teenage conscience. It is difficult.

As I thoroughly enjoyed listening to The LIturgists’ podcast on Fake News and Media Literacy,
their tongue-in-cheek rap (“1. Who wrote this S***,  2. Who published it?”) has run through my head
nonstop for two days. It made me laugh, if a bit ruefully because I may get in trouble if I taught it to my
freshmen, fresh out of middle school, whose mothers still put their hands over their mouths when a
curse word flies by. But the podcasters are right. People need to consider the source, look for dates,
and look for the sensationalization of material. I appreciated the list of questions to ask which were
practical and song-worthy. Combating “Fake News” is, as we are all seeing play out on the larger political
field, more important than ever. Discernment is the watchword of this age. We would do well to gain this
critical skill.

In the Framework for Information Literacy for Higher Education  (2015),  I really appreciated the
“Dispositions” section which stated

Learners who are developing their information literate-abilities:
  • respect the original ideas of others;
  • value the skills, time, and effort needed to produce knowledge;
  • see themselves as contributors to the information marketplace rather than only consumers of it;
  • are inclined to examine their own information privilege (p. 7).

Indeed, these are lofty standards to achieve for any student, and worthy goals for teachers to ingrain
into the minds of every student. Information is powerful, but it is not free. It is created on the sweat and
genius of everyone who has endeavored to learn something valuable, and who deserves respect and
reflection in addition to credence and credit.

I am on my school’s STEAM Leadership Team, which initially has focused on the 4 C’s, (also found in
the P21 Framework for 21st Century Learning) and these too intersect with literacy, technology, and
digital media. While certainly it is possible to think critically without technology, 1:1 devices have made
Web 2.0 tools the go-to choice for education. They are engaging and collaborative, stretching students
beyond their initial skills into a world-wide web of creativity and connection. The critical thinking this
involves to navigate these spaces is vast, but ultimately it will prepare students for what is to come
in the future.

My own information diet involves an embarrassingly large amount of podcasts, a Feedly stuffed to the
max with edtech and English teacher blogs, many professional development books, and a vast array of
fiction and non-fiction. I have become an information junkie, always listening to audiobooks or podcasts
while I drive, cook, or clean, and reading in my “spare” time. I notice lately that there just isn’t enough
time in the day, and I may need to slow the stream somewhat to allow time to reflect on and implement
the myriad of ideas that invade my consciousness on a daily basis.

As for the information diet of a librarian, I imagine that it would be much like my own, except to include
more professional materials that cater to librarianship. Journals and selection materials will need to be
added to my diet of daily reading, as will newsfeed about ALA-related issues. I imagine teacher blogs
may be replaced by librarian blogs, but then again, I may not need to compromise, as my new role
of teacher-librarian should be able to synthesize the material.

References
American Association of College and Resource LIbraries. (2015). Framework for information
literacy for higher education. Retrieved from http://www.ala.org/acrl/standards/ilframework
Gunger, M. & Johnson, C (Hosts). (2017 March 7). The liturgists [Audio podcast]. Retrieved from
Partnership for 21st Century Skills. 21st century learning skills. Retrieved from 



Comments

  1. I really relate to your intro to this blog post about your students, especially the resources they try to use! The Prezi presentations... I'm so glad that Prezi has semi-died, at least in my school world. Why do they love to cite other students' work so much, even when it's riddled with typos?

    I'd love to learn more about Feedly. Anything that can corral articles or posts sounds useful!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ashley, Feedly is amazing! It basically subscribes to any blog and houses everything in one site! I really love it.

      Delete
  2. When I taught English, I usually would do the research work for the students when presenting background information. I really like your idea of introducing big units by having students do the research. This gives them more of a buy in because it's already something we would be discussing in class. I usually made research its own unit, but it makes a lot more sense for students to be doing research as they go because that simulates how they will be evaluating sources once they graduate.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I used to present all the background knowledge also, but then I realized I was the one doing the work (and the learning). This has really helped. Research is engaging and informative. I kept getting frustrated that my students were such poor researchers (and writers using MLA format). When we began doing more mini research papers, that has helped. Smaller papers more often is the key. If I only did one big research unit a year (or even a semester) I'd probably forget how to cite my sources too!

      Delete
  3. Hi Linda,

    First, this was really well written. You are 100% correct. There is just not enough time in the day to stay on top of everything. The speed at which information is being uploaded online and the many ways people are presenting it to users is constant. By the time we info gurus feel comfortable in our research strategies and practices, another loophole has been created that we will have to work around in order to decipher between credible and poor information/sources. I had an email come through to my inbox the other day. I had just ordered a handful of things on Amazon. The email claimed to be Amazon informing me that my billing address needed to be updated and that until I updated the info my order would be placed on hold. I opened the link and saw the series of info it was asking me to provide including my social security number. The social security number was the huge flag that drove me back to look at the clarity of the original email and the Amazon logo. It was definitely not an email from the real Amazon and I had been so worried about not getting my packages on time and my order being placed on hold that I almost (almost) filled all the info out in a rush to receive my things. It seems, these days, that our information diet has to be as speedy, clever, and quick as the internet itself. There is so much our students need to know about not only the information they're looking for but the information that they happen to come across.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Manny,
      I am glad you followed your gut and looked into the source of the emails! This past summer, I kept getting calls about the Social Security Office "cancelling" my number if I didn't call back. I was initially a bit alarmed until I did some digging and realized it was a scam. It always pays to take a closer look!

      Delete
  4. The first thing I thought of when you mentioned looking for dates was when I see people on Facebook sharing news articles that are outdated without posting a newer update, such as if someone is missing, but they were found two years ago. I don't understand why people don't check the dates, which is why I think it is very important to teach this early on. I love that you mentioned using creativity to connect these standards with learning experiences. I think that is a way for students to really remember the lessons they are taught.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

National School Library Standards and ISTE Standards (A Comparison)

Sharing is Caring: Two Tech Tools You Can Use in Your Library or Classroom Today (Post #3)